County News

Who should pay?

Posted: Nov 19, 2026 at 10:18 am   /   by   /   comments (5)

Council pauses farm development charge collection

A$33,000 development charge on a new dairy barn brought the cost of farm investment into focus as Prince Edward County Council considered relief for agricultural operations at its final meeting of the term.

At its final meeting of the term, Council voted November 10 to seek recommendations on exempting eligible farm buildings from development charges, with a report expected in the first quarter of 2027. An amendment also directed staff to stop collecting charges on qualifying agricultural projects in the meantime. The decision pauses collection while the municipality examines a permanent exemption.

The proposal, brought forward by councillors Bill Roberts and Sam Branderhorst, would target registered farm businesses and non-residential buildings primarily supporting their operations. Their resolution cited industry figures placing agriculture’s contribution to the County economy at approximately $260 million, supporting roughly 1,800 agri-food jobs.

For third-generation dairy farmer David Prinzen, the issue was immediate.

Prinzen told Council he launched his farming venture in 2020 and had worked through the pandemic and several difficult seasons. Just as his business was finding firmer footing, construction of a new barn brought a $33,000 development charge. A manure pit attracted another $1,800 charge.

Together, he said, the charges exceeded what he earned last year.

Prinzen questioned why investment in agricultural production should carry charges intended to pay for infrastructure needed to accommodate growth. He argued that his farm buildings would create little additional demand for many of the services those charges support.

Don Williams, a seventh-generation dairy farmer from Bloomfield and second vice-president of the Prince Edward Federation of Agriculture, also urged Council to act promptly.

Williams said farmers were already facing bills for projects underway, while others were preparing to build. He told Council the Federation had not been consulted when the charges on farm buildings were introduced and characterized the loss of the exemption as a clerical error.

The appeals found considerable support around the council table. Staff, however, cautioned that removing the charges required a clearer understanding of the financial and legal consequences.

Among the questions were which buildings would qualify, how an exemption would affect the municipality’s development charge framework and whether farmers who had already paid could receive refunds.

Staff also stressed the need to distinguish buildings serving registered agricultural businesses from other commercial uses operating in former farm buildings.

Development charges help municipalities pay for the additional infrastructure required by new development. They generally apply when building permits are issued and are intended to recover growth-related capital costs. They are separate from the fees charged to process and inspect a building permit.

Whether agricultural buildings should attract those charges has been a longstanding concern for farm organizations.

The Ontario Federation of Agriculture argues that barns, silos, livestock facilities and other production buildings do not create the same infrastructure demands as new residential development. It supports exempting agricultural structures while treating new farm residences like other new homes.

In a November 2025 submission to the province, the Federation reported that approximately 72 per cent of municipal development charge bylaws already included agricultural building exemptions. It called for a province-wide exemption to replace the differing municipal approaches.

At the County horseshoe, councillors’ efforts to provide immediate relief ran into concerns about the outgoing council’s restricted authority.

Staff advised that Council’s lame duck status limited its ability to make unbudgeted financial commitments exceeding $50,000. With the potential value of an exemption or suspension still unknown, staff urged councillors to await a full analysis.

The discussion also raised the complexity of changing seven bylaws and determining how previously paid charges should be treated.

Council ultimately supported the report and interim collection pause, leaving the incoming council to consider how a lasting exemption could work and what relief might be available to agricultural operations that have already paid.

Staff’s review is expected to return in the first three months of 2027.

Comments (5)

write a comment

Comment
Name E-mail Website

  • Nov 19, 2026 at 11:44 am Susan

    Farming is a Commercial Business quite similar to any other commercial business that pays development charges. So why do they seek a privilege over others? There are some very wealthy farming operations in the County. Also since Councilor Branderhorst is a registered farmer, bringing forward this motion could be viewed as a direct conflict of interest resulting in financial gain.

    Reply
    • Nov 19, 2026 at 12:20 pm Teena

      Gee. And since when have the 2018-2022 / 2022-2026 Council members ever paid attention to Conflict of Interest? Let’s see – accepting campaign donations from developers; PECAHC Governance Team having five members of Council onboard, but not one of them declaring COI during meetings – stacking the deck a little here?; a member of council voting on event venues during Planning and Council meetings when by rights he should be declaring COI as his own venue is going through the planning process? No doubt there’s more, but nobody seems concerned about this – sameoldsameoldsameold, eh?

      However, I digress.

      Agriculture should be exempt. Full Stop.

      Food supply – remember? Not to mention that there was no consultation with the Prince Edward Federation of Agriculture (PEFA). They were not consulted at all about the changes, suggesting the matter hasn’t been handled very professionally. And they should have been. PEC is primarily a rural agricultural community. Read the article in countylive.ca as well. This is important. Someone messed up at Shire Hall and Staff don’t seem to know when, who, or why. Yet.

      Mind you, I’d kind of like to see the cows at the library.

      Reply
    • Nov 19, 2026 at 12:42 pm Parachute Packing

      @susan Respectfully, I think you are missing the point I’m trying to make.

      There appears to be ZERO “additional infrastructure required” by My. Prinzen’s barn or manure pit.

      The Development Charges are meant to ” help municipalities pay for the additional infrastructure required by new development. ”

      Neither Mr. Prinzen’s new barn nor his manure pit require any County money or investment. He is paying the entire cost.

      Perhaps, though, you are not missing my point, and instead, you believe that all taxpayers should help out developers by sharing in the costs of their developments.

      Perhaps you have accepted the narrative that “growth is good for everyone” and therefore “everyone should pay for growth”.

      I have not accepted that narrative. If developers wish to develop real estate, they should factor all of the costs into their plans.

      FWIW, when I built my house here in the County starting in 2019, I paid over $7K in “Development charges”, despite the fact that I was building in a rural lot with no connection to any County services. I paid 100% of my infrastructure costs, and continue to do so. When I asked what the money was to cover, I got the rather curt answer “the charges are based on the by-law” and a reference to the by-law allowing the County to charge them.

      Since I had no option at that point but to pay, if I wanted to move ahead, I absorbed the cost myself. And now when I see the County development charges being spent on infrastructure that only benefits outside developers, it makes me very sad.

      Perhaps you are saying “too bad, so sad, just deal with it”. Well, I am. But I will never accept the narrative that private developers should be subsidized with taxpayer money, especially to the degree that has left the County in a negative net worth situation approaching MINUS $100 million with annual interest in the millions, being paid to the Province, who downloads as much as they can to municipalities that either can not or will not push back.

      Enough.

      Reply
  • Nov 19, 2026 at 11:00 am Parachute Packing

    The article says:

    “Development charges help municipalities pay for the additional infrastructure required by new development. They generally apply when building permits are issued and are intended to recover growth-related capital costs. They are separate from the fees charged to process and inspect a building permit.”

    There appears to be ZERO “additional infrastructure required” by My. Prinzen’s barn or manure pit.

    Let’s call this what it is: a cash grab by the municipality, to fund “additional infrastructure required” by outside developers such as Base 31, Kaitlin, New View Holdings, Nicholas St., Cold Creek and other such initiatives.

    Such developer-initiated infrastructure should be funded by the developers. Period. If they cannot afford to build the developments without County money, then call that what it is: a blatant move to shift financial risk from themselves to taxpayers.

    Time for our new Mayor and Council to stand up and decide who should really be supported, and who should NOT be tapped to fund infrastructure for outside developers bent on exploiting weak municipalities.

    Reply
    • Nov 19, 2026 at 11:00 am Parachute Packing

      Excuse typo in previous post, should have read “Mr. Prinzen’s”.

      Reply